A Bagel Shop the Shore Deserves
All Star Bagel & Grill opened in Forked River to do one thing right: fresh bagels, made from scratch, every single morning. Chris and his wife are behind the counter every day — and that's exactly the point.
All Star Bagel & Grill | Our Story
A Shop Forked River Calls Its Own
Tucked on South Main Street near Barnegat Bay, All Star became a neighborhood fixture through sheer consistency — not advertising. If you're from here, you already know the Saturday morning line.
Made From Scratch, Every Morning
The dough is made fresh daily using unbleached, unbromated flour and filtered water — no preservatives, no shortcuts. Every bagel that comes out of this shop was made the same morning you're eating it.
The Pork Roll Sandwich Question
In New Jersey, pork roll, egg, and cheese on a bagel isn't just breakfast — it's a benchmark. Regulars call All Star's version the best in the region, and around here, that's not something people say casually.
Plain, Everything, Jalapeño Cheddar—and More
From plain and sesame to honey wheat, blueberry, and jalapeño cheddar — every basket is filled fresh before most people have had their first cup of coffee.
Chris, His Wife, and the Regulars
Laura Stanfield put it plainly: "They have a forever customer from me." When the owners know your name and your order, every morning feels like it matters — because to them, it does.